90s | Movies | Pop Culture

'The Craft' Almost Had An Entirely Different Cast And Now We Can't Unsee It

Columbia Pictures

As October 31st approaches, we can't help but re-watch all of our favorite Halloween flicks from back in the day. While the typical slasher movies are popular this time of year, there's nothing wrong with opting for something a little more fun. I mean, you can never go wrong with Hocus Pocus or Halloweentown, but sometimes we also need to give underrated movies, like The Craft, a chance.

IMDB

The spooky film had all the elements of a perfect 90s Halloween movie, including a quadrant of witches, cool special effects, Catholic school girl-meets-goth outfits to inspire your next costume, cheesy lines, and of course a stellar cast featuring the uniquely named Skeet Ulrich.

InStyle

In addition to Ulrich, the movie also starred Robin Tunney, Neve Campbell, Rachel True and Fairuza Balk as the high school misfits who discover the true meaning of having strength through witchcraft.

There's been rumors about a possible reboot by Sony, and as the chatter gets louder, we hear something new about the original movie everyday like how the movie almost had totally different lead actresses.

The casting director recently sat down for an interview with Entertainment Weekly and revealed which popular actresses almost had a role in the cult classic.

Casting director Pam Dixon and director Andrew Fleming admitted that casting the young women was one of the biggest hurdles they faced.

"There was not a generation of teen actors that you could draw from at that point," said Fleming, referring to the mid-90s.

It took them nine months to a make the final decision on the actresses who would play the roles of the four witches, Rochelle, Bonnie, Nancy and Sarah. Several actresses that we've come to love tried for a part in the movie, but Tunney, Campbell, True, and Balk beat out over 600 hopefuls.

Some of the actresses who were in the running include:

Alicia Silverstone

sweetshortandstylish.com

Scarlett Johansson

Zntent

And Angelina Jolie

Twitter

We can't even begin to imagine what the movie would be like if it featured these other actresses.

Dixon also revealed other interesting tidbits about the casting process including the fact that they didn't need much convincing to cast Campbell because not only did she do "really, really good" at the audition, her popularity on the show Party of Five made her "the biggest name" of them all.

Bustle

It wasn't until the right girls were all cast that the studio gave Fleming the green light to start filming.

"When we finally found four, I said, 'Let’s do this thing where the girls walk toward the camera in their witchy attire,' and we did it in slow motion and we put Portishead over it so that you got the feel of the movie," explained Fleming.

He continued, "What got the movie finally greenlit was when we shot the four girls walking. That image made the studio say, 'Okay, I get this.'"

Guess we owe Dixon and her team a huge thank you for helping create such a badass movie that 20 years later still resonates with us.

Could you imagine the movie with different lead actresses? Let us know!

More Throwbacks

90s

25 Years After Leaving Bayside High, Here's What The Cast of "Saved By The Bell" Are Up To Now

AOL TV named Saved By The Bell one of the "20 Best School Shows of all Time," and I'm sure everyone who's reading this article can agree with that sentiment. The American TV sitcom aired from 1989 to 1993, but has recently been classified as "educational and informational." That's cool and all, but it was also super-duper funny. It was one of the shows we looked forward to the most in the early '90s, and it helped launch the careers of some of these teen actors. Houston Chronicles Here's what the main cast of the show have been up to!

00s

6 Fishy Facts From "Finding Nemo" That Will Make You Just Keep Swimming

You may have a pretty decent memory, but have you forgotten that Pixar's Finding Nemo came out nearly 15 years ago in 2003? The now classic film about a father in search of his kidnapped son has become of the most popular movies of the new millennium. With its complex, emotional plot line, it captured our hearts in a net that we couldn't es-cap-ay!If you loved this movie from the deep blue sea, then check out these awesome facts - they're a real catch!Father FigureOh My DisneyThe story was originally written by Andrew Stanton, who based the plot

Movies

7 Things From 'National Treasure' That Were Actually 100% True

When Nicolas Cage took on the leading role of Benjamin Franklin Gates in the first installment of National Treasure, he showed us how awesome it would be to become a treasure hunter. He also showed us how awesome American history can be once you get below the textbook definitions of it. The story follows Cage's character, Ben Gates, as he attempts to steal the Declaration of Independence so that the bad guys don't get it first. The movie runs on the premise that there is a secret treasure map on the back of the document, and that it will lead

80s

15 Totally Cool Facts About 'The Blues Brothers'

When the Blues Brothers made their debut on SNL nobody had any idea what to make of them, but by the time Jake and Elwood made the jump to the big screen they had no shortage of fans.Their classic comedy adventure still makes us laugh almost 40 years later, but we bet you never realized these 15 facts about the movie.1. Dan Aykroyd saved Carrie Fisher's life, then popped the questionUniversal PicturesAykroyd and the late Star Wars actress hit it off on set and became an item. But after Aykroyd saved Fisher's life, he decided to take their

80s

What Kind Of Excellent Adventure Has Alex Winter Been On Since We Saw Him Last?

After starring in a few of the biggest movies of the the late 80s and early 90s, Alex Winter seemed to vanish from the big screen. The Lost Boys came out in 1987, and it was absolutely amazing. Just two years later he returned in the comedy classic Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure, where he was playing Bill S. Preston Esq., and going on the trip of a lifetime. Warner Bros. He followed it up by coming back for the sequel, Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey, but after that, he realized he wanted more. Winter wanted to be a bigger part of